Hole Fishing Fish Index
41 fish documented — day & night catches, all rarities. Updated September 2026.
Common(10)
The bread-and-butter starter fish. A golden variant exists.
Small river fish, ~9 kg. Golden Tench mutation confirmed.
Tiny but frequent. Giant Shrimp mutations sell for thousands.
Often confused with Shrimp in the index.
Reliable early filler catch.
Huge Clownfish mutations exist.
Colorful starter fish.
Small but pretty. Every player catches one early.
Slightly heavier than other commons — early rods may struggle.
Spooky but common. Easy night-index filler.
Uncommon(5)
Often your first $200+ catch. Leaps out of the hole.
Surprisingly good value for its size.
Huge Uncommon Snapper mutations are a known flex.
Common night catch.
Cheap for a night fish, but fills the index.
Rare(9)
Value scales hard with sell-value upgrades — a mid-game money maker.
Flashy catch, decent early payday.
Looks like a baby seal. Adorable and valuable.
~30 kg. Famous for being catchable on weak rods — the classic first 'big' catch.
Why is there an alligator in the hole? Nobody knows. Sell it anyway.
Skeletal fish. No special cutscene, but a solid rare.
Gets a dramatic catch animation despite being mid-tier. Classic fake-out.
Night exclusive. Squid money adds up fast.
Night exclusive, decent value.
Epic(7)
Epic tier starts here. Noticeable money jump.
Epic Blue Carp is a mid-game cash cow — farm these.
Fast and flashy.
~65 kg. Big Rare Octopus mutations confirmed.
Yes, it looks like Patrick. No, you can't catch a SpongeBob.
Steady epic money. Seen in server holes often.
Night-time epic that pays like a legendary. Prioritize night fishing.
Legendary(5)
~1.5 tons. Often the first legendary players see.
Big payday. Expect a cutscene.
Top-tier legendary. One catch can fund a full rod tier.
Weighs half a ton. The night-fishing legend that makes millionaires.
Ugly, rare, expensive.
Mythical(3)
Secret(2)
Day vs Night Fishing
Hole Fishing has a day/night cycle. Night-exclusive fish — Squid, Jellyfish, Moray Eel, Lionfish, Ghost Catfish, and the legendary Asian Turtle — sell for significantly more than day catches. Filling your night index grants the same +luck milestones as the day index, so don't sleep on it.
Mutations
Any fish can spawn as a Big, Large, Huge or Giant mutation (and Golden variants exist too). Mutations multiply both weight and value — a Huge Uncommon Snapper can out-earn a base Epic.